The Official GOAT List: Ranking the Greatest Donuts of All Time

Donuts

What is the best donut?

Ask ten people and you’ll get ten different answers.

Some swear the Glazed Donut is perfection — if a shop can’t nail the glaze, nothing else matters.

Others say the only serious donut is the Old-Fashioned, the crunchy cake donut built for coffee.

Fans of filled donuts argue the real champions are Boston Cream, Jelly, or Bavarian Cream.

And then there are the rebels.

The Apple Fritter — chaotic, crispy, and barely shaped like a donut.

The Cronut — the croissant-donut hybrid that started bakery lines around the world.

This league puts the most iconic donuts head-to-head so fans can decide.

Is the Glazed Donut the benchmark every bakery must beat?

Is the Apple Fritter secretly the best donut in the case?

Or does the Old-Fashioned prove texture beats toppings?

Vote in the battles and build your GOAT List.

Want to suggest a contender? Sign In

All Time ranks by all-time win rate across every head-to-head battle. Latest ranks by latest fan sentiment, updated as new battles are voted on.

1. APPLE FRITTER

62.3% win rate

#1 Greatest Donuts of All Time

T2. BOSTON CREAM

59.7% win rate

Tied for the #2 Greatest Donuts of All Time

T2. GLAZED DONUT

59.7% win rate

Tied for the #2 Greatest Donuts of All Time

4. BAVARIAN CREAM

53.8% win rate

#4 Greatest Donuts of All Time

5. OLD-FASHIONED DONUT

52.8% win rate

#5 Greatest Donuts of All Time

6. CHOCOLATE FROSTED DONUT

52.4% win rate

#6 Greatest Donuts of All Time

7. JELLY DONUT

46.9% win rate

#7 Greatest Donuts of All Time

8. BLUEBERRY CAKE DONUT

44.5% win rate

#8 Greatest Donuts of All Time

9. SOUR CREAM DONUT

43.4% win rate

#9 Greatest Donuts of All Time

10. MAPLE BAR

41.6% win rate

#10 Greatest Donuts of All Time

11. CRULLER

38.6% win rate

#11 Greatest Donuts of All Time

12. CRONUT

34.7% win rate

#12 Greatest Donuts of All Time