The Best Toast Toppings, Ranked by Fan Votes
GoatWars fans rank Butter the greatest of all time among Toast Toppings, with a 67.0% Goatscore.
Chasing the crown: #2 Jelly (60.9%), #3 Cinnamon Sugar (57.4%).
A warm piece of toast is easy. Choosing what goes on it is where people get serious. Are you taking melted butter every time? Peanut butter? Nutella? Do you want avocado and a fried egg, or are you keeping it simple with honey, jelly, or cinnamon sugar?
There is no polite answer here — just the topping you would choose if you only got one. Vote through the head-to-head battles and help settle the ultimate toast debate.
All Time ranks by all-time win rate across every head-to-head battle. Latest ranks by latest fan sentiment, updated as new battles are voted on.
GOAT List FAQs
Who is the greatest of all time among Toast Toppings?
GoatWars fans rank Butter the greatest of all time among Toast Toppings, with a 67.0% Goatscore.
How is the GOAT List calculated?
The GOAT List ranks every contender in Toast Toppings by Goatscore: the percentage of head-to-head GoatWars battles they have won, as voted by fans.
How many votes is this ranking based on?
This GOAT List is based on 1,117 fan votes in head-to-head battles, as of September 25, 2026.
Other Popular Food Leagues To Battle In
Thanksgiving Desserts
Girl Scout Cookies
Fast Food Mascots
Sports Drinks