Peanut Butter

Peanut butter doesn't play around. It turns toast into an actual meal and somehow works whether it's breakfast, lunch, or a midnight snack. Creamy versus crunchy is already its own civil war before you even compare it to other toppings. Some people add bananas or honey, but plenty argue it doesn't need any help. It fills you up, sticks with you, and delivers comfort in every bite. Its biggest rivals are Nutella for the sweet crowd and butter for the traditionalists. If you believe the best toast should actually keep you full, peanut butter belongs near the top.