What's the Best Girl Scout Cookie of All Time? You Decide.

You see the Girl Scout cookie table outside the grocery store, and suddenly your self-control disappears. Are you grabbing a sleeve of Thin Mints for the freezer, a box of coconut-covered Samoas, or those chocolate-and-peanut-butter Tagalongs? Maybe you're loyal to the buttery simplicity of Trefoils or still mourning a discontinued favorite. Everybody has their go-to box, and everybody thinks their pick deserves the crown. From chocolate-covered classics to lemony surprises, we're settling the sweetest argument of cookie season. Which Girl Scout cookie actually deserves GOAT status? Pick your favorites in head-to-head matchups and let the fans decide.