Adventurefuls

Adventurefuls came into the Girl Scout cookie conversation ready to compete with the richest options in the lineup. With a brownie-inspired chocolate cookie, caramel-flavored crème, and a touch of sea salt, they're clearly not interested in playing the simple-cookie game.

They're made for people who want their cookies to feel like dessert. Chocolate lovers get their fix, caramel fans have something to celebrate, and that little salty finish keeps the sweetness interesting.

But Adventurefuls face a difficult challenge. They're competing against cookies people have been buying since childhood. Thin Mints and Samoas have years of personal memories working in their favor.

Can a newer, richer contender overcome that nostalgia advantage? Or will Adventurefuls prove that the greatest Girl Scout cookie doesn't necessarily have to be the one you grew up eating?