Tagalongs (Peanut Butter Patties)

Chocolate and peanut butter have been winning snack arguments forever, and Tagalongs are bringing that combination straight into the Girl Scout cookie championship. A crisp cookie base, a generous layer of peanut butter, and a chocolate coating make these dangerously easy to finish.

Tagalongs don't need coconut, mint, or complicated flavors to make their case. They're rich, satisfying, and built around a combination that rarely disappoints. For peanut butter lovers, this might be the easiest vote in the entire league.

But here's the question: does being an incredible chocolate-peanut-butter cookie make Tagalongs the greatest Girl Scout cookie? Thin Mints have the tradition. Samoas have the texture. Tagalongs have the kind of flavor combination people crave year-round. Is that enough to take the crown?