The Official GOAT List: Ranking the Greatest Fictional Pets of All Time

Fictional Pets

Dive into the Greatest Fictional Pets of All Time debate on GoatWars and you'll find more passion than a soap opera showdown. Why? Because whether it's Snoopy's cool demeanor or Garfield's lasagna obsession, these aren't just pets; they're icons that shaped our lunchboxes and our lives. Fans go head-to-head over the absurd—like which pet would save you in a fictional apocalypse or who rocked the best accessories (hello, Scooby's collar!). It's a battleground of nostalgia meets nitpicking where every choice can stir a childhood memory or spark a heated debate. The cultural stakes? Immense. Each pick isn't just a vote; it's a tribute to Saturday mornings spent in pajamas, watching these legends on screen.

Want to suggest a contender? Sign In

All Time ranks by all-time win rate across every head-to-head battle. Latest ranks by latest fan sentiment, updated as new battles are voted on.

1. SNOOPY (PEANUTS)

75.1% win rate

#1 Greatest Fictional Pets of All Time

2. SCOOBY-DOO (SCOOBY-DOO)

66.9% win rate

#2 Greatest Fictional Pets of All Time

3. GARFIELD (GARFIELD)

52.6% win rate

#3 Greatest Fictional Pets of All Time

4. PLUTO (DISNEY)

50.3% win rate

#4 Greatest Fictional Pets of All Time

5. DINO (THE FLINTSTONES)

49.6% win rate

#5 Greatest Fictional Pets of All Time

6. LASSIE (LASSIE)

47.4% win rate

#6 Greatest Fictional Pets of All Time

7. TOTO (THE WIZARD OF OZ)

42.6% win rate

#7 Greatest Fictional Pets of All Time

8. BRIAN GRIFFIN (FAMILY GUY)

40.4% win rate

#8 Greatest Fictional Pets of All Time

9. SALEM SABERHAGEN (SABRINA THE TEENAGE WITCH)

40.0% win rate

#9 Greatest Fictional Pets of All Time

10. OLD YELLER (OLD YELLER)

35.4% win rate

#10 Greatest Fictional Pets of All Time