Old Yeller (Old Yeller)

If Old Yeller doesn't top your list of Greatest Fictional Pets, you might need to check your nostalgia settings. This dog did more than just fetch sticks; he fetched our hearts and hasn't given them back. Now, trying to argue with an Old Yeller fan about the greatest pet? It's like telling them Santa isn't real — brace yourself for a battle. And let's be honest, the only thing sadder than the movie's ending is trying to claim any other pet could beat him in GoatWars. Good luck, other pets, you'll need it!