The ice cream is only the beginning. Are you flooding the bowl with hot fudge, burying it under Oreo crumbles, going full candy shop with Reese’s Pieces, or keeping it classic with sprinkles and whipped cream? Ice cream toppings create some vicious little arguments because everybody has a combination they swear by. Sauce people want maximum gooeyness. Crunch people need texture. Cookie-dough people are basically ordering dessert on top of dessert. We’re putting the classics head-to-head until one topping owns the sundae. Pick your matchups and build your GOAT list.