Reese’s Pieces
Reese’s Pieces bring the candy aisle straight into the ice cream bowl. You get a crisp shell, peanut butter in the middle, bright color across the top, and plenty of little pieces to chase around with your spoon. They also open a completely different lane in this bracket. Hot fudge and caramel own the sauces. Oreos and brownies bring baked-dessert energy. Reese’s Pieces are pure candy-shop chaos. Their toughest matchup might actually be chopped peanuts: does peanut flavor work better sweet and candy-coated, or salty and crunchy? And when they run into Oreo crumbles, you’re basically choosing which snack deserves to invade your ice cream. That’s a fight worth having.
Reese’s Pieces's Rankings
Ice Cream Toppings
Rank: #8 (see rankings)
Win Rate: 42.9%
Streak: ❄️ 2-match losing streak
Best matchups (highest win rate)
- Reese’s Pieces vs Chopped Peanuts - Wins 78.6% of battles
- Reese’s Pieces vs Sprinkles - Wins 62.5% of battles
- Reese’s Pieces vs Maraschino Cherries - Wins 52.9% of battles
Worst matchups (lowest win rate)
- Reese’s Pieces vs Hot Fudge - Loses 85.0% of battles
- Reese’s Pieces vs Brownie Pieces - Loses 73.3% of battles
- Reese’s Pieces vs Chocolate Chips - Loses 68.4% of battles