home ⟩ Pop Culture & Characters ⟩ Fictional Pets ⟩ Old Yeller (Old Yeller) vs. Garfield (Garfield)

Greatest Fictional Pets of All Time
Old Yeller (Old Yeller) or Garfield (Garfield)

Pick Your Favorite

OLD YELLER (OLD YELLER)

VS

GARFIELD (GARFIELD)
0%

Your GOAT List

Why This Battle Matters

Can the unflinching loyalty of Old Yeller ever truly compete with the laid-back charm of Garfield? This isn't just a battle of classic vs. modern; it's a showdown that challenges our very notion of what we cherish in our fictional companions. On one side, there's the heart-wrenching heroics of a loyal canine from the wild frontier. On the other, a lasagna-loving cat whose biggest adventures happen between naps. The winner here doesn't just top the charts; they redefine the essence of greatness in the league. As fans, your choice answers a poignant question: Do we value the comfort of humor, or the nobility of sacrifice?

🔥 Fan Takes

Honestly, comparing a legend like Old Yeller to a lasagna-loving cat? That's rough, man.
lol, why even compare? Garfield wins, sleeps all day & hates Mondays. #Mood
Old Yeller is a hero, y'all. Breaks my heart every time. 😭

How Fans Are Voting

In this battle:

Fans currently prefer Garfield (Garfield) over Old Yeller (Old Yeller) when it comes to the greatest Fictional Pets of all time. In head-to-head matchups, fans pick Garfield (Garfield) 85.0% of the time over Old Yeller (Old Yeller).

Across all battles:

Garfield (Garfield) win rate: 52.0%

Old Yeller (Old Yeller) win rate: 35.0%

Fan FAQs

Who's the top contender in the Greatest Fictional Pets of All Time on GoatWars?

Snoopy from Peanuts currently holds the crown as the top contender in this league. Check out where Garfield, Old Yeller, and other beloved pets rank on the GOAT List.

What's the deal with fans adoring Old Yeller?

Old Yeller is the epitome of a loyal and brave pet, winning hearts with his protective nature and compelling story. His emotional impact on audiences, especially with his heroic deeds, really makes him a beloved character in the history of fictional pets.

Why is Garfield winning by so much in the Greatest Fictional Pets of All Time league?

It's all about the charm and humor Garfield brings to the table. Fans can't get enough of his sarcastic wit and love for lasagna, which makes him a standout character that resonates with so many. Plus, being a comic strip star gives him a lot of visibility and nostalgia points!