home ⟩ Movies & TV ⟩ Nickelodeon Shows ⟩ iCarly vs. All That

Greatest Nickelodeon Shows of All Time
All That or iCarly

Pick Your Favorite

ALL THAT

VS

ICARLY
0%

Your GOAT List

Why This Battle Matters

Imagine a world where slapstick meets savvy technology — that's the crux of today's GoatWars battle between the innovative antics of iCarly and the timeless sketch comedy of All That. Here, we're not just deciding which show made us laugh more; we're determining which represents the pinnacle of Nickelodeon's creative spirit. iCarly brought the digital revolution to kids' TV, integrating social media trends before they were mainstream, while All That was a breeding ground for future stars, setting the stage with its raw comic essence. As we weigh modernity against legacy, ask yourself: which show truly captured the essence of your Nickelodeon nostalgia?

🔥 Fan Takes

So we're just gonna pretend All That wasn't the blueprint? Please 😂 iCarly's fun but it's standing on the shoulders of giants here.
Bro, how are we even debating this? iCarly was my whole childhood, fr. All That was cool but come on, it's iCarly all the way!
iCarly is iconic, no cap! They've got the humor AND the heart. All That's cool but doesn't hit the same, y'know?

How Fans Are Voting

In this battle:

Fans currently prefer iCarly over All That when it comes to the greatest Nickelodeon Shows of all time. In head-to-head matchups, fans pick iCarly 56.2% of the time over All That.

Across all battles:

iCarly win rate: 55.9%

All That win rate: 39.1%

Fan FAQs

Why is this matchup between iCarly and All That such a big debate?

This head-to-head brings up major debates because it pits a modern sitcom against a classic sketch show, each defining Nickelodeon for different generations. Fans are torn whether to vote for the innovative web show vibe of iCarly or the original comedy staple that is All That.

What makes All That so popular among fans?

All That is like the SNL for the Nickelodeon crowd, known for its wild skits and launching the careers of several teen stars. Its variety-show format and memorable characters keep fans coming back for the nostalgia and laughs.

Why is iCarly currently leading in the fan votes over All That?

iCarly is snagging more votes probably because it hits that sweet nostalgia for many who grew up with internet shows. Its quirky humor and relatable characters like Carly and Sam resonate deeply with fans who tuned in during their own formative years.