All That vs iCarly
iCarly leads with 58% of votes
See full Nickelodeon Show rankings →Pick Your Favorite
VS
Your GOAT List
The Real Debate
iCarly brings the charm of a modern teen web show to the battle, while All That reigns as the original sketch comedy king that shaped Nickelodeon's golden era. This clash isn't just about picking a favorite show; it's an all-out war between spontaneous digital antics and classic comedic sketches, testing which style resonates more with fans. iCarly's fresh, internet-savvy humor meets All That's timeless, slapstick ensemble - a battle of new school cool versus old school rules. Which side are you on? Dive in and vote, because your choice says a lot about which era of Nickelodeon shaped you!
🔥 Fan Takes
How Fans Are Voting
In this battle:
Fans currently prefer iCarly over All That when it comes to the greatest Nickelodeon Shows of all time. In head-to-head matchups, fans pick iCarly 58.8% of the time over All That.
Across all battles:
iCarly win rate: 56.7%
All That win rate: 38.9%
Fan FAQs
What's at stake in the iCarly vs All That matchup?
This battle pits nostalgia against modern flair. iCarly's fresh take on teen life contrasts with All That's classic comedic sketches, giving fans a tough choice between innovative content and nostalgic comedy.
What makes All That so popular in the Greatest Nickelodeon Shows of All Time league?
All That holds a special place for fans because of its SNL-style sketch comedy that influenced a whole generation. It launched the careers of several major stars and has that nostalgic factor that keeps fans coming back for more.
Why is iCarly currently leading over All That?
Fans seem to connect more with iCarly because of its modern take on teenage life and its creative use of the internet and web shows within the plot. Its humor and relatability give it an edge over All That's more traditional sketch comedy format.