Greatest Nickelodeon Shows of All Time - Are You Afraid of the Dark? or Drake & Josh

Ever wondered which Nickelodeon universe you’d rather live in—the uproarious living room of Drake & Josh or the eerie glow of a midnight circle from Are You Afraid of the Dark? Here lies the essence of this GoatWars battle: slapstick shenanigans versus spine-tingling suspense. It's a duel between the light-hearted antics of suburban siblings and the chilling tales that shaped our braver selves. What’s at stake? It's more than pride; it's about which narrative power held us captive, demanding our laughter or our screams. Now, think—do you cherish the comfort of humor, or do you thrive on the thrill of fear?