iCarly

If iCarly isn’t at the top of your 'Greatest Nickelodeon Shows of All Time' list, then, my friend, you need to recalibrate your humor sensors. Remember trying to explain to your mom why spaghetti tacos are a legit dinner option? Or the odd satisfaction of watching Spencer craft something bizarre yet genius? This show didn’t just push the envelope; it mailed it to Mars. Fans get it—iCarly is less of a show and more of a lifestyle. Pick a side, because in the realm of GoatWars, fence-sitting is for the amateurs.