home ⟩ Sports ⟩ NFL Running Backs ⟩ Earl Campbell vs. Emmitt Smith

Greatest NFL Running Backs of All Time
Earl Campbell or Emmitt Smith

Pick Your Favorite

EARL CAMPBELL

VS

EMMITT SMITH
0%

Your GOAT List

Why This Battle Matters

What happens when unstoppable force meets the enduring spirit? Earl Campbell, known for his ferocious running style that often left defenders in disarray, versus Emmitt Smith, whose endurance and vision turned the turf into his personal stage. This isn't just a battle of powerful legs and record books; it's about sheer will against strategic brilliance. At stake? The shaping of the legacy and who truly epitomizes the heart of a champion. Which value speaks to you louder—raw power or graceful longevity?

🔥 Fan Takes

I mean, choosing between Emmitt and Earl is tough... but Emmitt might edge it just a bit? Still love both!
Honestly, Earl Campbell had that raw power tho, feels unfair to just glance over him!
Emmitt Smith, no question! Guy's a legend. Earl who? 🤣

How Fans Are Voting

In this battle:

Fans currently prefer Emmitt Smith over Earl Campbell when it comes to the greatest NFL Running Backs of all time. In head-to-head matchups, fans pick Emmitt Smith 64.6% of the time over Earl Campbell.

Across all battles:

Emmitt Smith win rate: 59.3%

Earl Campbell win rate: 44.7%

Fan FAQs

Why is this matchup between Emmitt Smith and Earl Campbell such a big debate among fans?

This debate heats up because it's a classic clash of era-defining talents — Emmitt's endurance and record-breaking stats vs. Earl's sheer physical dominance and intense playing style. Both sides have passionate fanbases who argue not just about stats, but about the impact and inspiration these legends provided during their careers.

What makes Earl Campbell so beloved among fans?

Earl Campbell is cherished for his fearsome running style and raw power. His ability to bulldoze through defenses and his incredible performances right from his rookie season have left a lasting impression, making him a favorite in the hearts of old-school football lovers.

Why is Emmitt Smith leading over Earl Campbell in the Greatest NFL Running Backs of All Time league?

Emmitt Smith is pulling ahead mainly because of his all-time rushing record and his crucial role in the Cowboys' dynasty. Fans resonate with his consistency and his knack for performing in crucial games, which really puts him a notch above in these heated debates.