The Official GOAT List: Ranking the Greatest Thanksgiving Desserts of All Time

Thanksgiving Desserts

The turkey's gone, the plates are stacked, and somehow everybody still has room for dessert. But what's actually the best part of the Thanksgiving dessert table? Pumpkin pie has generations of tradition behind it, pecan pie has its ride-or-die defenders, and apple pie never shows up without a crowd. Then you've got sweet potato pie, cheesecake, banana pudding, and peach cobbler threatening to steal the whole holiday. Are you sticking with the classics or grabbing something different before it's gone? These desserts aren't just competing for a slice of your plate. They're fighting for Thanksgiving bragging rights. Vote head-to-head and decide which dessert deserves the crown.

Want to suggest a contender? Sign In

All Time ranks by all-time win rate across every head-to-head battle. Latest ranks by latest fan sentiment, updated as new battles are voted on.

T1. APPLE CRISP

0.0% win rate

Tied for the #1 Greatest Thanksgiving Desserts of All Time

T1. APPLE PIE

0.0% win rate

Tied for the #1 Greatest Thanksgiving Desserts of All Time

T1. BANANA PUDDING

0.0% win rate

Tied for the #1 Greatest Thanksgiving Desserts of All Time

T1. BREAD PUDDING

0.0% win rate

Tied for the #1 Greatest Thanksgiving Desserts of All Time

T1. CHEESECAKE

0.0% win rate

Tied for the #1 Greatest Thanksgiving Desserts of All Time

T1. CHERRY PIE

0.0% win rate

Tied for the #1 Greatest Thanksgiving Desserts of All Time

T1. CHOCOLATE CREAM PIE

0.0% win rate

Tied for the #1 Greatest Thanksgiving Desserts of All Time

T1. PEACH COBBLER

0.0% win rate

Tied for the #1 Greatest Thanksgiving Desserts of All Time

T1. PECAN PIE

0.0% win rate

Tied for the #1 Greatest Thanksgiving Desserts of All Time

T1. PUMPKIN CHEESECAKE

0.0% win rate

Tied for the #1 Greatest Thanksgiving Desserts of All Time

T1. PUMPKIN PIE

0.0% win rate

Tied for the #1 Greatest Thanksgiving Desserts of All Time

T1. SWEET POTATO PIE

0.0% win rate

Tied for the #1 Greatest Thanksgiving Desserts of All Time