The Official GOAT List: Ranking the Greatest Pizza Toppings of All Time

Pizza Toppings

Dive into the Greatest Pizza Toppings of All Time debate, and you're in the arena where passions flare over whether pineapple is a pizza pioneer or a taste bud treason. It's not just food—it's a culinary showdown with team Pineapple throwing down against the staunch Pepperoni purists. Every choice from mushrooms to jalapeños isn't just a preference, it's a statement. And don't get me started on the anchovy advocates; they're a whole different breed of devoted. This debate has seen friendships tested and family dinners turned into topping trials. It's the ultimate battle of taste, tradition, and the brave souls who dare to top their pie with something new. Who knew a slice of pizza could hold so much drama?

Want to suggest a contender? Sign In

All Time ranks by all-time win rate across every head-to-head battle. Latest ranks by latest fan sentiment, updated as new battles are voted on.

1. PEPPERONI

72.7% win rate

#1 Greatest Pizza Toppings of All Time

2. SAUSAGE

58.5% win rate

#2 Greatest Pizza Toppings of All Time

3. MUSHROOMS

54.3% win rate

#3 Greatest Pizza Toppings of All Time

4. BACON

54.0% win rate

#4 Greatest Pizza Toppings of All Time

5. BLACK OLIVES

46.8% win rate

#5 Greatest Pizza Toppings of All Time

6. ONIONS

37.6% win rate

#6 Greatest Pizza Toppings of All Time

7. PINEAPPLE

34.2% win rate

#7 Greatest Pizza Toppings of All Time

8. GREEN PEPPERS

32.0% win rate

#8 Greatest Pizza Toppings of All Time