The Official GOAT List: Ranking the Greatest Insurance Mascots of All Time

Insurance Mascots

You can probably quote at least one of these commercials without even trying. Some mascots made insurance feel friendly. Others made it hilarious, weird, or completely unforgettable. This isn't about who sells the best policy—it's about who owned TV, became part of pop culture, and stuck in your head for years. Flo vs. Jake. Gecko vs. Mayhem. The Aflac Duck vs. The General. Every matchup feels obvious until you actually have to pick. Start voting.

Want to suggest a contender? Sign In

All Time ranks by all-time win rate across every head-to-head battle. Latest ranks by latest fan sentiment, updated as new battles are voted on.

1. MAYHEM (ALLSTATE)

76.4% win rate

#1 Greatest Insurance Mascots of All Time

2. GEICO GECKO

66.1% win rate

#2 Greatest Insurance Mascots of All Time

3. FLO (PROGRESSIVE)

61.2% win rate

#3 Greatest Insurance Mascots of All Time

4. PROFESSOR BURKE (FARMERS INSURANCE)

52.2% win rate

#4 Greatest Insurance Mascots of All Time

5. AFLAC DUCK

48.9% win rate

#5 Greatest Insurance Mascots of All Time

6. JAKE FROM STATE FARM

45.8% win rate

#6 Greatest Insurance Mascots of All Time

7. LIMU EMU (LIBERTY MUTUAL)

39.8% win rate

#7 Greatest Insurance Mascots of All Time

8. THE GENERAL (GENERAL)

21.7% win rate

#8 Greatest Insurance Mascots of All Time

9. ERIN (ESURANCE)

6.5% win rate

#9 Greatest Insurance Mascots of All Time