The Official GOAT List: Ranking the Greatest Ice Cream Brands of All Time

Ice Cream Brands

Dive into the creamy, dreamy world of the 'Greatest Ice Cream Brands of All Time' on GoatWars where ice cream isn't just a treat—it's a full-blown cultural showdown. Picture this: you've got Häagen-Dazs with its luxuriously rich texture squaring off against Ben & Jerry’s and its wild mix-in madness. Then there’s the timeless charm of Blue Bell against the nostalgic pull of Dreyer’s/Edy’s. Fans get down to the nitty-gritty over things like mouthfeel, flavor innovation, and even cone compatibility! It’s a deliciously fierce debate where every scoop counts, and honestly, the intensity is what makes it so entertaining. From historical flavor comebacks to regional loyalty wars, this battle has it all. So, scoop up your favorite and let's get swirling in this frosty fray!

Want to suggest a contender? Sign In

All Time ranks by all-time win rate across every head-to-head battle. Latest ranks by latest fan sentiment, updated as new battles are voted on.

1. BEN & JERRY’S

69.5% win rate

#1 Greatest Ice Cream Brands of All Time

2. HÄAGEN-DAZS

62.3% win rate

#2 Greatest Ice Cream Brands of All Time

3. COLD STONE CREAMERY

54.8% win rate

#3 Greatest Ice Cream Brands of All Time

4. BLUE BELL

53.4% win rate

#4 Greatest Ice Cream Brands of All Time

5. TALENTI GELATO & SORBETTO

52.4% win rate

#5 Greatest Ice Cream Brands of All Time

6. BREYERS

48.5% win rate

#6 Greatest Ice Cream Brands of All Time

7. JENI'S SPLENDID ICE CREAMS

38.7% win rate

#7 Greatest Ice Cream Brands of All Time

8. MAGNUM

38.2% win rate

#8 Greatest Ice Cream Brands of All Time

9. DREYER’S / EDY’S

37.9% win rate

#9 Greatest Ice Cream Brands of All Time

10. BLUE BUNNY

27.9% win rate

#10 Greatest Ice Cream Brands of All Time