The Official GOAT List: Ranking the Greatest Baseball Players of All Time
Share My GOATLIST
Babe Ruth. Barry Bonds. Shohei Ohtani. Derek Jeter. Pete Rose. Different legends. Different definitions of greatness. Is baseball about dominance, championships, skill, longevity, intimidation, or integrity? From Ruth’s mythic power and Bonds’ controversial peak to Ohtani’s two-way revolution and Rose’s lifetime ban, every contender represents a different answer. One philosophy wins. The rest were just great players.
Read more
Want to suggest a contender?
Sign In
All Time
Latest
All Time ranks by all-time win rate across every head-to-head battle.
Latest ranks by latest fan sentiment, updated as new battles are voted on.
81.4% win rate
#1 Greatest Baseball Players of All Time
66.5% win rate
#2 Greatest Baseball Players of All Time
61.2% win rate
#3 Greatest Baseball Players of All Time
54.2% win rate
#4 Greatest Baseball Players of All Time
51.7% win rate
#5 Greatest Baseball Players of All Time
46.7% win rate
#6 Greatest Baseball Players of All Time
44.8% win rate
#7 Greatest Baseball Players of All Time
43.1% win rate
#8 Greatest Baseball Players of All Time
37.6% win rate
#9 Greatest Baseball Players of All Time
30.6% win rate
#10 Greatest Baseball Players of All Time
27.3% win rate
#11 Greatest Baseball Players of All Time
21.9% win rate
#12 Greatest Baseball Players of All Time
Sentiment 1808
#1 Baseball Players by latest sentiment
Sentiment 1700
#2 Baseball Players by latest sentiment
Sentiment 1646
#3 Baseball Players by latest sentiment
Sentiment 1524
#4 Baseball Players by latest sentiment
Sentiment 1521
#5 Baseball Players by latest sentiment
Sentiment 1513
#6 Baseball Players by latest sentiment
Sentiment 1466
#7 Baseball Players by latest sentiment
Sentiment 1440
#8 Baseball Players by latest sentiment
Sentiment 1387
#9 Baseball Players by latest sentiment
Sentiment 1354
#10 Baseball Players by latest sentiment
Sentiment 1320
#11 Baseball Players by latest sentiment
Sentiment 1320
#12 Baseball Players by latest sentiment
College Football Programs