VS
Your GOAT List
Is the triumph of a bygone hero more stirring than the fresh feats of a modern legend? James Street and Major Applewhite aren't just names; they're eras clashing, traditions challenging innovations, and long-held beliefs meeting new-age dynamism. Street's perfect season and Applewhite's record-setting performances encapsulate more than just games won; they represent two distinct philosophies of athletic excellence and leadership. As Major Applewhite currently edges ahead, the real question emerges: Will fans lean towards historic perfection or the relatable resilience of breaking barriers in newer times?
In this battle:
Fans currently prefer Major Applewhite over James Street when it comes to the greatest University of Texas Quarterbacks of all time. In head-to-head matchups, fans pick Major Applewhite 100.0% of the time over James Street.
Across all battles:
Major Applewhite win rate: 64.3%
James Street win rate: 34.8%
Vince Young stands as the top contender in the Greatest University of Texas Quarterbacks league. His unforgettable performances, especially in the 2006 Rose Bowl, have left a lasting impact, making him a fan favorite and often the first name that comes up in discussions about UT greats.
James Street holds a special place in Longhorn history with his perfect record as a starter and his crucial role in the 1969 national championship. His knack for clutch plays and leadership in critical games creates a nostalgic reverence among older fans.
Major Applewhite has a strong following thanks to his impressive stats and the modern era appeal. His games are fresher in fan memories and his strategic plays often get highlighted in discussions, giving him a significant edge in fan votes over the legendary but older era hero, James Street.