Greatest "That Guy" Character Actors of all time

Gary Cole vs William Fichtner

Two legends. One pick. No fence-sitting.

The Real Debate

William Fichtner brings a magnetic intensity to every role, while Gary Cole offers a subtle, yet powerful, versatility that morphs seamlessly from drama to comedy. This clash of titans in the 'That Guy' Character Actors League is a cinematic tug-of-war between Fichtner's explosive unpredictability and Cole's understated mastery, compelling fans to fiercely defend their favorite. Whether it's Fichtner's edgy performances that have left audiences on the edge of their seats or Cole's ability to disappear into any role, sparking admiration across genres, this battle isn't just about who acts better—it's about what style of acting resonates more deeply with you. As the votes pour in, bringing them to a nerve-racking tie, it's your turn to tip the scales. Choose your champion—whose legacy on screen truly captures the spirit of greatness?

Head-to-Head Comparison

Criteria Edge Why
Face Recognition Gary Cole Gary Cole's roles in popular series like 'The Office' and 'Veep' make his face more instantly recognizable.
Scene Stealing William Fichtner William Fichtner, with his intense presence, often overshadows even the main actors, especially in films like 'Heat'.
“Ohhh That Guy” William Fichtner Fichtner's diverse roles across genres make him a classic 'Ohhh that guy' even if his name doesn't come to mind immediately.
Movie Resume Gary Cole Gary Cole's broad spectrum of memorable roles, from comedy to drama, gives him a slightly more diverse and recognizable filmography.
Gary Cole vs. William Fichtner

Fan Takes

Honestly, it’s tough. Both actors bring such depth to their roles. Fichtner's intensity vs. Cole's charm—it's like choosing between comfort and thrill!
idk but like, William Fichtner is THAT GUY!! if he shows up in a movie, you know it’s gonna be like 1000% better, fr 😂
I just can't get over how Gary Cole has been in my life since 'Office Space'. It’s like he’s my comfort food in movies! 🍕

How Fans Are Voting

Latest battle odds:

Gary Cole: 71%

William Fichtner: 29%

Overall battle results:

Overall fans prefer William Fichtner over Gary Cole when it comes to the greatest "That Guy" Character Actors of all time. In head-to-head matchups, fans pick William Fichtner 56.5% of the time over Gary Cole.

Across all battles:

William Fichtner win rate: 51.7%

Gary Cole win rate: 50.0%

Fan FAQs

Why is this matchup such a big debate in the Greatest 'That Guy' Character Actors of All Time league?

It's a clash of two iconic styles! Fichtner brings this gritty intensity, while Cole has a laid-back charm that fans adore. Each has their own loyal fanbase, and that makes the stakes high! The GOAT List for Greatest "That Guy" Character Actors of All Time shows where everyone else lands.

What makes Gary Cole so popular?

Fans can't get enough of Gary Cole's versatility and charisma. From his memorable characters in comedies to his serious roles, he has this knack for connecting with audiences and leaving a lasting impression.

Who is better: William Fichtner or Gary Cole?

Right now, William Fichtner's taking the lead, and fans seem to love his unique roles and intense performances. But Gary Cole has a massive following too, so it's definitely a lively debate!

Not done arguing?

Next "That Guy" Character Actors fight, picked for you.

Keep voting →