Greatest Super Bowl Halftime Shows of All Time - Lady Gaga (2017) or Janet Jackson & Justin Timberlake (2004)
Pick Your Favorite
VS
Your GOAT List
Why This Battle Matters
What happens when a scandalous wardrobe malfunction collides with a high-flying solo spectacle? You get the Janet Jackson & Justin Timberlake (2004) versus Lady Gaga (2017) showdown. This isn't just a battle of performances; it's a cultural clash of the unexpected versus the meticulously planned. On one side, a moment that sparked debates and a media frenzy, and on the other, a display of raw talent and audacity that reshaped what a halftime show could be. What's at stake? A chance to redefine the narrative of Super Bowl halftime fame. Which moment resonates more with today's culture - the shocking or the sublime?
🔥 Fan Takes
How Fans Are Voting
In this battle:
Fans currently prefer Janet Jackson & Justin Timberlake (2004) over Lady Gaga (2017) when it comes to the greatest Super Bowl Halftime Shows of all time. In head-to-head matchups, fans pick Janet Jackson & Justin Timberlake (2004) 60.0% of the time over Lady Gaga (2017).
Across all battles:
Janet Jackson & Justin Timberlake (2004) win rate: 42.1%
Lady Gaga (2017) win rate: 50.0%
Fan FAQs
Why is this matchup such a big debate?
It's a classic throwdown between two unforgettable shows that represent very different eras and styles of pop music. Janet & Justin's show is wrapped in spectacle and controversy, while Lady Gaga's performance is all about empowerment and artistry. Fans are torn because each show has its own unique appeal.
What makes Lady Gaga's 2017 halftime show still so beloved?
Lady Gaga brought her A-game with a mix of vocal prowess and dazzling theatrics. Fans adore her for the way she literally soared during her performance, making it a visual and musical spectacle that matched her larger-than-life persona.
Why is Janet Jackson & Justin Timberlake's 2004 show winning by so much in the Greatest Super Bowl Halftime Shows league?
Fans are really vibing with the nostalgia and the dramatic impact of that 2004 performance. It's iconic not just for the music and choreography, but for the controversy and the endless conversations it sparked. That moment has lasted in public memory, pushing Janet and Justin way ahead in the votes.