Greatest Pizza Styles of all time

New York Style Pizza vs St. Louis-Style Pizza

Two picks. One winner. No fence-sitting.

The Real Debate

The battlefield is set with two giants of the pizza world: New York Style Pizza boasts its hand-tossed, thin crust under layers of savory marinara and bubbling mozzarella, while St. Louis-Style Pizza counters with a cracker-thin crust, Provel cheese, and square cuts that defy tradition. Here, it's a showdown of the Big Apple's iconic, foldable slices versus the Gateway City's distinct, cheesy bite. This duel isn't just about taste—it's about identity, with New Yorkers' no-nonsense, walk-and-eat lifestyle clashing against St. Louis' methodical, sit-and-savor approach. As fans fiercely defend their regional pride, the lines are drawn: will tradition reign supreme, or will innovation capture the crown? Choose your side and cast your vote in this epic pizza showdown!

Head-to-Head Comparison

Criteria Edge Why
Crust Game New York Style Pizza New York Style's hand-tossed, thin crust stands out for its perfect chewy-to-crisp ratio, setting a high bar universally loved.
Crave Factor New York Style Pizza The iconic, foldable slices of New York Style create an irresistible craving that folks often seek out across the country.
Pizza Night Vibes New York Style Pizza Nothing beats grabbing a large, foldable slice while watching a game or movie, making it a go-to for an authentic pizza night.
Heat Level St. Louis-Style Pizza St. Louis-Style pizza boasts a unique diehard fanbase, passionately defending its cracker-like crust and Provel cheese against all comers.
New York Style Pizza vs. St. Louis-Style Pizza

Fan Takes

It's like New York-style embodies the hustle of the city—bold, unapologetic, while St. Louis is more like that quiet kid in the back of class. Can’t we just appreciate both for what they are? Still, NY reigns supreme.
st. louis pizza is literally like if someone asked a pizza to be a cracker lol 🤣 they gotta step up their game!
omg ny pizza has my heart forever ❤️ there's just something about that thin crust and all that cheese, ya know?

How Fans Are Voting

Latest battle odds:

New York Style Pizza: 79%

St. Louis-Style Pizza: 21%

Overall battle results:

Overall fans prefer New York Style Pizza over St. Louis-Style Pizza when it comes to the greatest Pizza Styles of all time. In head-to-head matchups, fans pick New York Style Pizza 66.0% of the time over St. Louis-Style Pizza.

Across all battles:

New York Style Pizza win rate: 67.1%

St. Louis-Style Pizza win rate: 51.0%

Fan FAQs

Why is this matchup such a big debate in the Greatest Pizza Styles of All Time league?

It's all about the clash of culture and style! New York's iconic reputation versus St. Louis's quirky take on pizza has fans passionately split, and each side is bringing their A-game to defend their beloved slice. Curious who else is in the mix? Check the GOAT List for Greatest Pizza Styles of All Time.

What makes St. Louis-Style Pizza so popular?

Fans dig St. Louis for its unique thin crust and that provel cheese, which is a total game-changer. Plus, there's a nostalgic charm about it that keeps people coming back, especially if you're from around there!

Who is better: New York Style Pizza or St. Louis-Style Pizza?

Right now, New York Style is leading the charge, and honestly, it's hard not to love that classic foldable slice! Fans are all about the crispy crust and cheesy goodness, while St. Louis just can't seem to keep up.

Not done arguing?

Next Pizza Styles fight, picked for you.

Keep voting →