Greatest Pizza Styles of all time

Detroit-Style Pizza vs New York Style Pizza

Two picks. One winner. No fence-sitting.

The Real Debate

New York Style Pizza flaunts a thin, crisp crust beneath its classic marinara and generous cheese topping, while Detroit-Style Pizza is known for its thick, rectangular base and characteristic crispy, cheesy edges. This culinary showdown taps deep into the passionate hearts of pizza aficionados everywhere, pitting the sleek, foldable slices of the Big Apple against the hearty, pan-baked squares from the Motor City. As fans rally behind their preferred slices, the air buzzes with debates over tradition versus innovation, simplicity versus complexity. Each style brings a rich history and a devoted fan base, making this tug-of-war about much more than just taste—it's about pride. It's time to weigh in: will you champion the elegant minimalism of New York, or the bold, boundary-pushing spirit of Detroit?

Head-to-Head Comparison

Criteria Edge Why
Crust Game Detroit-Style Pizza Detroit-style's thick, crispy caramelized cheese edge offers a unique and irresistible crust experience.
Crave Factor New York Style Pizza New York Style Pizza's thin, foldable slices have a universal appeal making people crave another slice instantly.
Pizza Night Vibes New York Style Pizza The shareable, large slices of New York Style Pizza create an ideal, laid-back atmosphere for any pizza night.
Heat Level Detroit-Style Pizza Detroit-style pizza, with its distinct square shape and crunchy base, often sparks passionate debates among enthusiasts.
Detroit-Style Pizza vs. New York Style Pizza

Fan Takes

Honestly, both styles have their merits, but New York's just feels like the classic hero in this pizza saga... you know what I mean?
Detroit style pizza? lol more like what's even the point? it's just a square mess 😂 #sorrynotsorry
new york pizza is like a memory wrapped in cheesy goodness. i grew up on it! can't beat that vibe! 🍕❤️

How Fans Are Voting

Latest battle odds:

New York Style Pizza: 68%

Detroit-Style Pizza: 32%

Overall battle results:

Overall fans prefer New York Style Pizza over Detroit-Style Pizza when it comes to the greatest Pizza Styles of all time. In head-to-head matchups, fans pick New York Style Pizza 67.9% of the time over Detroit-Style Pizza.

Across all battles:

New York Style Pizza win rate: 67.1%

Detroit-Style Pizza win rate: 59.8%

Fan FAQs

Who do you think has the edge in the Greatest Pizza Styles of All Time league: New York Style Pizza or Detroit-Style Pizza?

Right now, New York Style Pizza is leading the pack, and honestly, it’s hard to beat that classic appeal. But Detroit fans are super passionate, making this matchup pretty spicy! The GOAT List for Greatest Pizza Styles of All Time shows where everyone else lands.

What makes Detroit-Style Pizza so popular?

Detroit-Style brings that unique square shape, crispy edges, and soft, chewy crust that fans can't get enough of. It feels like comfort food that wraps you in a cheesy hug!

Why is New York Style Pizza winning by so much?

Fans are all about that iconic fold and the killer street slice! Plus, the nostalgia and love for the Big Apple's pizza culture really fuels the momentum.

Not done arguing?

Next Pizza Styles fight, picked for you.

Keep voting →