home ⟩ Sports ⟩ NFL Running Backs ⟩ Walter Payton vs. Emmitt Smith

Greatest NFL Running Backs of All Time
Emmitt Smith or Walter Payton

Pick Your Favorite

EMMITT SMITH

VS

WALTER PAYTON
0%

Your GOAT List

Why This Battle Matters

Is it the relentless grace of Walter Payton or the unstoppable power of Emmitt Smith that defines greatness? In this monumental clash, every choice echoes through the halls of NFL history, pitching Sweetness against the all-time leading rusher. Here, it's not just about yards gained but legacies carved. Whose era-shaping dominance will fans honor? This battle doesn't just decide who was better; it's a reflection of what we value in our heroes—elegance under pressure or sheer unyielding force.

đŸ”„ Fan Takes

Trying to pick between Payton and Smith is like choosing my favorite pizza topping: impossible.
lol remember when football was just football and not a stats class? sweetness forever, guys
Emmitt was good, but c'mon, Walter Payton’s style was poetry in motion.

How Fans Are Voting

In this battle:

Fans currently prefer Walter Payton over Emmitt Smith when it comes to the greatest NFL Running Backs of all time. In head-to-head matchups, fans pick Walter Payton 57.1% of the time over Emmitt Smith.

Across all battles:

Walter Payton win rate: 70.7%

Emmitt Smith win rate: 60.3%

Fan FAQs

Who's the #1 contender in the Greatest NFL Running Backs of All Time league?

Barry Sanders is leading the pack in the Greatest NFL Running Backs of All Time league. If you're curious about how all the legends stack up, check out the GOAT List.

Why is this matchup between Walter Payton and Emmitt Smith so close?

It’s a nail-biter because both players have such passionate fanbases and legendary careers. Payton's style was all about finesse and power, while Smith’s consistency and longevity in the game earned him massive respect. Fans are really torn between these two styles and legacies!

Who's currently winning the head-to-head battle between Walter Payton and Emmitt Smith in the Greatest NFL Running Backs of All Time league?

Walter Payton is slightly ahead in the votes right now, winning fans over presumably with his incredible agility and the sheer heart he showed on the field. Plus, that nickname 'Sweetness' just sticks with you!