home ⟩ Sports ⟩ Kentucky Derby Winners ⟩ Barbaro vs. Secretariat

Greatest Kentucky Derby Winners of All Time
Barbaro or Secretariat

Pick Your Favorite

BARBARO

VS

SECRETARIAT
0%

Your GOAT List

Why This Battle Matters

Imagine if the thrill of the Kentucky Derby could be distilled into a single, electrifying moment: Barbaro and Secretariat, shoulder to shoulder, thundering towards the finish line. This isn't just about who was faster on a spring day decades apart; it's a clash of eras, of heartbreak against perfection, of raw potential cut tragically short versus a legacy as enduring as the Churchill Downs itself. What's at stake here is more than a spot on a leaderboard—it's about which story captures our imagination the most. As these titans of the track vie for supremacy, ask yourself: which champion's tale resonates deeper with the spirit of the Derby?

🔥 Fan Takes

idk guys, both are legends, but Secretariat kinda runs circles in my head, ya know?
no way, can't just dismiss Barbaro like that, he's got heart, memories man, memories.
lol Barbaro was great but Secretariat? Bro was like the Beyonce of horse racing.

How Fans Are Voting

In this battle:

Fans currently prefer Secretariat over Barbaro when it comes to the greatest Kentucky Derby Winners of all time. In head-to-head matchups, fans pick Secretariat 91.7% of the time over Barbaro.

Across all battles:

Secretariat win rate: 94.2%

Barbaro win rate: 40.2%

Fan FAQs

What makes this matchup between Barbaro and Secretariat such a monumental debate?

The debate is heated because it's a classic matchup of 'what could have been' with Barbaro's tragically short career versus 'what was' with Secretariat's historic achievements. Fans are passionate, comparing Barbaro's raw talent and heart-wrenching story with Secretariat's enduring legacy and record-breaking performances.

Why is Secretariat winning by so much in the Greatest Kentucky Derby Winners league?

Secretariat's overwhelming lead in the fan voting isn't surprising. His 1973 Triple Crown victory, marked by a breathtaking 31-length win in the Belmont Stakes, has carved him a permanent, celebrated spot in horse racing history. This nostalgia and continued reverence likely fuel his dominance in the votes.

Who is better: Barbaro or Secretariat?

Fan consensus on GoatWars lean heavily towards Secretariat, who's far ahead in the voting. His record-shattering win at the Derby and his legendary status among racing enthusiasts really seem to pull the fans in his favor.