American Pharoah vs Secretariat
Secretariat leads with 95% of votes
See full Kentucky Derby Winner rankings →Pick Your Favorite
VS
Your GOAT List
The Real Debate
While American Pharoah broke the 37-year Triple Crown drought in 2015, Secretariat, the 1973 legend, continues to reign supreme with a record-shattering performance that still mesmerizes fans. The debate rages on: does Pharoah's modern-day heroics capture the imagination as strongly as the historical spectacle of Secretariat's 31-length Belmont victory? It's a clash of eras, a contest between the recent champion and the timeless icon. As debates heat up, fan loyalties split—do you stick with the nostalgic power of Secretariat or champion the fresh triumphs of American Pharoah? Choose your legend, cast your vote, and witness the ultimate showdown in Kentucky Derby history!
🔥 Fan Takes
How Fans Are Voting
In this battle:
Fans currently prefer Secretariat over American Pharoah when it comes to the greatest Kentucky Derby Winners of all time. In head-to-head matchups, fans pick Secretariat 95.1% of the time over American Pharoah.
Across all battles:
Secretariat win rate: 94.2%
American Pharoah win rate: 29.3%
Fan FAQs
Why is this matchup between Secretariat and American Pharoah such a big debate in the league?
Both horses have left unforgettable marks on the Kentucky Derby, but they come from different eras with different styles of dominance. Secretariat's record-setting performance in 1973 against American Pharoah’s 2015 superstardom sets up a classic old vs. new debate that keeps fans arguing and voting fervently.
What makes American Pharoah still popular despite the wide margin?
American Pharoah captured hearts by ending the Triple Crown drought after 37 years. His charm, alongside the excitement of his races, still holds a special place in racing fans' hearts. He might be trailing, but his fan base remains passionate and loyal.
Why is Secretariat dominating American Pharoah so much in the Greatest Kentucky Derby Winners of All Time?
It’s all about legacy! Secretariat is not just a name; it's a legend that resonates with fans of all ages. His stunning records and the emotional impact of his victories have left a lasting impression. American Pharoah is incredible, but Secretariat is often seen as the epitome of horse racing greatness.