home ⟩ Sports ⟩ Kentucky Derby Winners ⟩ Whirlaway vs. American Pharoah

Greatest Kentucky Derby Winners of All Time
American Pharoah or Whirlaway

Pick Your Favorite

AMERICAN PHAROAH

VS

WHIRLAWAY
0%

Your GOAT List

Why This Battle Matters

In the realm of titans and legends, does the spectacle of Whirlaway's 1941 whirlwind-like Triple Crown victory outshine the modern majesty of American Pharoah's 2015 sweep, the first in nearly four decades? Here lies a battle not just between two champions, but between eras of dominance and innovation in horse racing. Whirlaway, with his erratic yet enchanting style, contrasts sharply with American Pharoah, a beacon of power and precision. This matchup isn't just about who crosses the finish line first; it's about which legacy resonates louder and which type of greatness the fans admire most. As this fierce clash gallops on, one must ask: What values in a champion do you hold dear?

🔥 Fan Takes

I mean, both are legends but am I the only one who thinks Whirlaway had that extra flair? That tail, iconic.
lol, why even argue? American Pharoah redefined the game. 🐐
Whirlaway's race in '41 was pure poetry, man. American Pharoah? Meh, not even close.

How Fans Are Voting

In this battle:

The contenders are currently tied in head-to-head matchups. Your vote will break the tie.

Fan FAQs

What's the appeal of American Pharoah in the Greatest Kentucky Derby Winners league?

American Pharoah broke a near-impossible drought to claim the Triple Crown in 2015, ending a longing that spanned generations of race fans. His calm demeanor yet explosive race power made him a modern icon, bridging the gap between past glories and the contemporary era. He not only represents hope but also the thrill of witnessing history being made.

What makes Whirlaway so admired among fans of the Greatest Kentucky Derby Winners of All Time?

Whirlaway, often remembered as 'Mr. Longtail,' captivated fans with his dramatic come-from-behind victories and his incredible speed and stamina. His iconic sweeping move in the 1941 Derby is the stuff of legend, making him a favorite for many traditional race enthusiasts.

Why is the matchup between Whirlaway and American Pharoah such a tight race?

It's neck and neck because both Whirlaway and American Pharoah have legendary statuses in the racing world. Whirlaway, with his astounding Triple Crown win in 1941, has the old-school charm and historical legacy, while American Pharoah, the first Triple Crown winner after a 37-year drought, holds a special place in recent memory. Fans are clearly split on this!