Greatest Kentucky Derby Winners of All Time
Barbaro or American Pharoah
Pick Your Favorite
VS
Your GOAT List
Why This Battle Matters
Can heart triumph over an undeniable dynasty? Barbaro, the symbol of resilience whose promise was tragically unfulfilled, faces off against American Pharoah, the Triple Crown titan who redefined modern racing. This isn't just about who was faster on a Kentucky Derby day—it's a clash of eras, the grit and raw potential of Barbaro against the sleek, history-making efficiency of American Pharoah. The stakes? More than just bragging rights; it's about defining what greatness truly means in the annals of horse racing. Which legacy resonates more with you?
🔥 Fan Takes
How Fans Are Voting
In this battle:
Fans currently prefer American Pharoah over Barbaro when it comes to the greatest Kentucky Derby Winners of all time. In head-to-head matchups, fans pick American Pharoah 75.0% of the time over Barbaro.
Across all battles:
American Pharoah win rate: 29.3%
Barbaro win rate: 40.2%
Fan FAQs
Why is this matchup between American Pharoah and Barbaro in the Greatest Kentucky Derby Winners league a big deal?
This head-to-head is a clash of titans — American Pharoah with his Triple Crown glory against the valiant and tragic figure of Barbaro. It's a matchup that really tugs at the heartstrings and sparks debate on what defines greatness in the annals of the Kentucky Derby.
What makes Barbaro still so beloved by fans?
Fans hold a deep emotional connection to Barbaro not just for his impressive win at the Derby but also for his courageous fight after his tragic accident in the Preakness. His spirit and the heartfelt saga that followed have left a lasting impact.
Why is American Pharoah winning by so much against Barbaro in the Greatest Kentucky Derby Winners of All Time league?
American Pharoah's commanding lead likely comes from his historic Triple Crown win in 2015, which ended a 37-year drought. Fans remember not just his Derby performance but his dominance across all three races, which really cements his legacy in horse racing history.