Two picks. One winner. No fence-sitting.
At the heart of this GoatWars battle lies a duel between the comforting warmth of McDonald's Apple Pie and the refreshing chill of a McDonald’s Soft Serve Cone. It's a clash of seasoned tradition against the pure, cool simplicity that has divided dessert enthusiasts for decades. On one hand, the apple pie, with its flaky, golden crust and spiced apple filling, speaks to a nostalgic, homestyle dessert experience. On the other, the soft serve cone, with its creamy texture and ice-cold satisfaction, offers a straightforward, delightful treat. With the stakes this high and the fans this divided, whose side are you on?
| Criteria | Edge | Why |
|---|---|---|
| Craving Power | McDonald’s Apple Pie | The unique warmth and spice of McDonald's Apple Pie sparks more craving than a typical ice cream. |
| First Bite | McDonald’s Apple Pie | The first bite of the crispy crust combined with soft, sweet apples delivers an instant flavor explosion unlike the more predictable ice cream cone. |
| Finishability | McDonald’s Soft Serve Cone | The Soft Serve Cone's smooth texture and moderate sweetness make it effortless to finish, even in large quantities. |
| Mess Factor | McDonald’s Soft Serve Cone | Ice cream cones are generally less messy, with a cone that contains the melting ice cream, as opposed to crumbly pie crusts that scatter easily. |
Latest battle odds:
McDonald’s Soft Serve Cone: 57%
McDonald’s Apple Pie: 43%
Overall battle results:
Overall fans prefer McDonald’s Soft Serve Cone over McDonald’s Apple Pie when it comes to the greatest Fast Food Desserts of all time. In head-to-head matchups, fans pick McDonald’s Soft Serve Cone 53.8% of the time over McDonald’s Apple Pie.
Across all battles:
McDonald’s Soft Serve Cone win rate: 47.4%
McDonald’s Apple Pie win rate: 49.0%
The McDonald's Soft Serve Cone is slightly ahead, and it's no surprise — fans love it for its classic appeal and refreshing taste. Curious who else is in the mix? Check the GOAT List for Greatest Fast Food Desserts of All Time.
It’s the simplicity and nostalgia of it all! You can't beat that creamy texture and the memories of getting one after a happy meal. Plus, it’s just so satisfying on a sunny day!
Fans are totally divided on this one! McDonald's Apple Pie has that nostalgic, warm comfort vibe, while the Soft Serve Cone is a classic treat that hits just right on a hot day. It’s like a delicious tug-of-war!