Greatest Fast Food Desserts of all time

McDonald’s Apple Pie vs Wendy’s Frosty

Two picks. One winner. No fence-sitting.

The Real Debate

The battle rages between the cool, creamy Wendy’s Frosty and the warm, flaky McDonald’s Apple Pie, contrasting not just in temperature but in texture and essence. On one side, we have the Frosty, a beloved, chocolatey staple of chilly indulgence since 1969, stirring up nostalgia with every spoonful. Opposite stands the iconic McDonald’s Apple Pie, bursting with tangy apple slices encased in a crispy, golden crust, a revolutionary reinvention of American tradition since its debut. These titans of taste don't just represent different flavors; they embody the clash of cooling comfort versus fiery, fruity zest. Fans, it's time to decide—will you dive into the smooth, frozen swirls or embrace the crackling, spiced embrace?

Head-to-Head Comparison

Criteria Edge Why
Craving Power Wendy’s Frosty The Frosty's rich, creamy texture sparks a stronger craving, especially as a comfort food.
First Bite McDonald’s Apple Pie The warm, spiced filling of the Apple Pie delivers an immediate taste sensation that's hard to beat.
Finishability Wendy’s Frosty Its smooth consistency makes the Frosty incredibly easy to keep sipping until the last drop.
Mess Factor McDonald’s Apple Pie Despite occasionally leaking filling, the Apple Pie’s contained format is generally neater than a melting Frosty.
McDonald’s Apple Pie vs. Wendy’s Frosty

Fan Takes

I mean, each dessert represents a piece of Americana; the Frosty speaks of nostalgia while the Apple Pie whispers comfort. Still, the Frosty just… hits different.
LOL the apple pie is basically just a glorified hand warmer tbh. Like, give me a break, it’s just baked. Frosty wins, easily! 😂
Honestly, the Frosty is like a warm hug from my childhood! Nothing beats dipping fries in that creamy goodness. 🥰

How Fans Are Voting

Latest battle odds:

Wendy’s Frosty: 68%

McDonald’s Apple Pie: 32%

Overall battle results:

Overall fans prefer Wendy’s Frosty over McDonald’s Apple Pie when it comes to the greatest Fast Food Desserts of all time. In head-to-head matchups, fans pick Wendy’s Frosty 68.8% of the time over McDonald’s Apple Pie.

Across all battles:

Wendy’s Frosty win rate: 65.8%

McDonald’s Apple Pie win rate: 49.0%

Fan FAQs

Why is the Wendy’s Frosty vs. McDonald’s Apple Pie matchup so talked about in the Greatest Fast Food Desserts of All Time league?

Both are iconic treats with passionate fanbases, but they represent totally different dessert vibes. The Frosty is all about creamy indulgence while the Apple Pie brings those warm, fruity memories, making this a heated debate for dessert lovers! The GOAT List for Greatest Fast Food Desserts of All Time shows where everyone else lands.

What makes McDonald’s Apple Pie so popular?

The crispy crust and warm, gooey filling really hit the spot, especially when you're craving something sweet. It's that classic comfort food vibe that just makes you feel good!

Why is Wendy’s Frosty winning by so much?

Fans can't get enough of the Frosty’s creamy texture and that perfect chocolatey taste! Plus, it’s a nostalgic favorite for so many who grew up getting one after a meal.

Not done arguing?

Next Fast Food Desserts fight, picked for you.

Keep voting →