Two picks. One winner. No fence-sitting.
McDonald’s Apple Pie brings nostalgia with every bite, harking back to fast food’s golden era, while Culver’s Concrete Mixer shakes things up with customizable, rich frozen custard loaded with mix-ins. It's a classic showdown between the iconic, universally recognized tart apple treat and a heavyweight, creamy contender that lets you craft your own dessert destiny. Fans on both sides are fiercely loyal, arguing whether tradition should reign supreme or if the freedom to personalize steals the show. As these desserts lock horns in a deliciously frosty and fruity faceoff, the question isn’t just what you're eating—it's what those choices say about you. Which will you choose: the comfort of an old favorite, or the thrill of new flavors?
| Criteria | Edge | Why |
|---|---|---|
| Craving Power | Culver’s Concrete Mixer | The customizable mix-ins of Culver's Concrete Mixer spark a compelling craving you can tailor to your mood. |
| First Bite | Culver’s Concrete Mixer | Culver's Concrete Mixer’s creamy richness provides an instant indulgent 'wow' factor that's hard to beat. |
| Finishability | McDonald’s Apple Pie | The compact and simple nature of McDonald's Apple Pie makes it effortlessly enjoyable to the last bite. |
| Mess Factor | McDonald’s Apple Pie | McDonald’s Apple Pie, with its handheld design, offers a tidy eating experience compared to the spoon-required, potentially drippy Concrete Mixer. |
Latest battle odds:
McDonald’s Apple Pie: 68%
Culver’s Concrete Mixer: 32%
Overall battle results:
Overall fans prefer McDonald’s Apple Pie over Culver’s Concrete Mixer when it comes to the greatest Fast Food Desserts of all time. In head-to-head matchups, fans pick McDonald’s Apple Pie 55.6% of the time over Culver’s Concrete Mixer.
Across all battles:
McDonald’s Apple Pie win rate: 49.0%
Culver’s Concrete Mixer win rate: 48.3%
This is such a hot topic because you’ve got the classic nostalgia of McDonald’s Apple Pie against the limitless creativity of Culver’s Concrete Mixer. Fans are split between tradition and innovation! Curious who else is in the mix? Check the GOAT List for Greatest Fast Food Desserts of All Time.
Fans love Culver’s Concrete Mixer because it’s got that customizable mix-in magic, plus it feels like a treat you can really make your own. Everyone appreciates the fresh ingredient vibe!
Right now, McDonald's Apple Pie is leading, and honestly, it's hard to beat that crispy, gooey goodness everyone remembers from their childhood!