Greatest Disney Movies of all time

Moana vs The Little Mermaid

Two picks. One winner. No fence-sitting.

The Real Debate

The Little Mermaid dives into the nostalgic depths of classic animation and timeless songs, while Moana sails on the waves of a modern tale of self-discovery and vibrant, new-age animation. Here we see a clash of eras: Ariel's undersea romance and rebellious spirit versus Moana's epic journey and her role as a leader redefining her people's future. Fans are torn between the enchanting traditional charm of Ariel and the empowering, boundary-pushing narrative of Moana. As these iconic heroines battle it out, which champion will you support—the cherished classic or the contemporary trailblazer? Cast your vote and make your voice heard in this thrilling Disney showdown!

Head-to-Head Comparison

Criteria Edge Why
Story Originality Moana Moana's exploration of Polynesian mythology offers a fresher narrative than the traditional fairy-tale approach of The Little Mermaid.
Character Development Moana Moana exhibits significant growth from a naive islander to a confident leader, showcasing a more pronounced character arc.
Visual Impact The Little Mermaid The undersea world of The Little Mermaid, filled with vibrant colors and imaginative creatures, creates a more enchanting visual experience.
Emotional Engagement Moana Moana's journey resonates deeply, packed with themes of self-discovery and cultural heritage that tug at the heartstrings.
Moana vs. The Little Mermaid

Fan Takes

Honestly, it's tough! The Little Mermaid has that timeless charm while Moana feels like a fresh breath of ocean air. Both are legends in their own right.
Moana's vibe is too good to pass up, plus those ocean waves are basically the best CGI i've ever seen lol. #TeamMoana 🌊💁‍♀️
The Little Mermaid is a classic! I still remember singing 'Part of Your World' as a kid. Nothing beats nostalgia! 🧜‍♀️✨

How Fans Are Voting

Latest battle odds:

Moana: 61%

The Little Mermaid: 39%

Overall battle results:

Overall fans prefer The Little Mermaid over Moana when it comes to the greatest Disney Movies of all time. In head-to-head matchups, fans pick The Little Mermaid 53.8% of the time over Moana.

Across all battles:

The Little Mermaid win rate: 48.4%

Moana win rate: 47.7%

Fan FAQs

Why is this matchup such a big debate in the Greatest Disney Movies of All Time league?

Both movies have passionate fanbases that cherish different aspects—while The Little Mermaid has that nostalgic feel, Moana represents a newer generation of storytelling. It's like a clash of classic versus modern, and everyone seems to have their favorite! The GOAT List for Greatest Disney Movies of All Time shows where everyone else lands.

What makes Moana so popular?

Fans love Moana for her adventurous spirit and determination. Plus, the stunning animation and catchy music just resonate with people of all ages—it’s hard not to get hooked!

Who is better: The Little Mermaid or Moana?

Right now, The Little Mermaid is leading, and I think fans are really drawn to its classic charm and nostalgia. The vibrant underwater world and unforgettable songs get people singing along!

Not done arguing?

Next Disney Movies fight, picked for you.

Keep voting →