Greatest Christmas Movie Characters of All Time
Rudolph (Rudolph the Red-Nosed Reindeer) or John McClane (Die Hard)

Pick Your Favorite

RUDOLPH (RUDOLPH THE RED-NOSED REINDEER)

VS

JOHN MCCLANE (DIE HARD)
0%

Your GOAT List

Why This Battle Matters

Is it bravery or brightness that defines the Christmas spirit? In this electrifying GoatWars matchup, we find the quintessential action hero, John McClane, pitted against the beacon of hope, Rudolph. McClane brings grit and a never-say-die attitude from the snowy Nakatomi Plaza, redefining what a Christmas hero looks like, while Rudolph’s luminous nose has been guiding Santa’s sleigh through the worst blizzards, embodying the traditional values of perseverance and kindness. This isn't just about who tops the list; it's a battle for the soul of Christmas tales. Will fans lean towards resilience or radiance? Your favorite symbolizes what stories we'll tell future generations.

🔥 Fan Takes

You're telling me a reindeer beats an action hero in a holiday showdown? Pls, the nostalgia blinds y'all.
lol John McClane saving Christmas with explosions? peak holiday spirit 😂
Rudolph with his nose so bright, guiding my childhood Christmas? Iconic!

How Fans Are Voting

In this battle:

The contenders are currently tied in head-to-head matchups. Your vote will break the tie.

Fan FAQs

What makes Rudolph so popular?

Rudolph is the ultimate underdog turned hero. His story of overcoming obstacles and leading Santa's sleigh has warmed hearts for generations. Plus, who can resist that glowing red nose?

Why do fans love John McClane?

John McClane is a hit with fans for his rugged charm and his 'never-say-die' attitude. He brings a non-traditional twist to Christmas, making 'Die Hard' a holiday favorite for those who prefer action over sweetness.

Why is this matchup between John McClane and Rudolph such a big debate?

Talk about an odd couple! You've got John McClane, the tough, wise-cracking cop from 'Die Hard', and Rudolph, the sweet, red-nosed reindeer who's a holiday staple. Fans are torn because it's a classic clash of unexpected Christmas hero versus traditional holiday icon.