Greatest Cat Movies of all time

Garfield: The Movie vs That Darn Cat!

Two picks. One winner. No fence-sitting.

The Real Debate

While 'That Darn Cat!' brings a classic, chaotic adventure of a mischievous feline aiding an FBI mission, 'Garfield: The Movie' offers a modern take with a lasagna-loving, lazy cat turned hero. Fans split hairs over which cat captures the essence of true feline mischief and charm — is it the cunning and agile D.C. from the 60s or the sardonic, comfort-seeking Garfield of the new millennium? This debate taps deep into our nostalgia versus contemporary preferences, urging fans to defend not just a movie, but the character that best reflects their own feline affections. It’s a showdown of legacy against modern wit, and every vote is a testament to personal favorites and movie memories. Pick your cat and cast your vote now!

Head-to-Head Comparison

Criteria Edge Why
Cat Energy That Darn Cat! That Darn Cat! captures the stealthy and curious nature of cats more realistically.
Rewatchability That Darn Cat! The quirky 60s charm of That Darn Cat! makes it a nostalgic rewatch.
Cat Chaos Garfield: The Movie Garfield, with his lasagna obsession and lazy antics, defines cat chaos with humor.
Heart That Darn Cat! The connection between the cat and its human counterparts in That Darn Cat! stirs more emotion.
Garfield: The Movie vs. That Darn Cat!

Fan Takes

Honestly, I get why people love both. But That Darn Cat! embodies adventure and heart, while Garfield feels like a meme in motion. Such a contrast!
lol not Garfield 😂 like, who decided that lazy cat was gonna be the icon? That Darn Cat is way more fun, fr.
That Darn Cat! is like nostalgia in a film. I watched it as a kid and it just hits ya right in the feels! 🐾

How Fans Are Voting

Latest battle odds:

That Darn Cat!: 70%

Garfield: The Movie: 30%

Overall battle results:

Overall fans prefer That Darn Cat! over Garfield: The Movie when it comes to the greatest Cat Movies of all time. In head-to-head matchups, fans pick That Darn Cat! 70.0% of the time over Garfield: The Movie.

Across all battles:

That Darn Cat! win rate: 49.6%

Garfield: The Movie win rate: 47.6%

Fan FAQs

Why is the Greatest Cat Movies of All Time league such a heated debate?

It's all about the love for these furry stars! That Darn Cat! and Garfield: The Movie offer such different vibes—one’s a classic caper while the other’s all about lazy humor. Fans are fiercely divided over which one truly deserves the crown. The GOAT List for Greatest Cat Movies of All Time shows where everyone else lands.

What makes Garfield: The Movie so popular?

Garfield has this iconic lazy attitude that fans just can’t resist! Plus, the humor appeals to both kids and adults, making it a favorite for family movie nights.

Why is That Darn Cat! winning by so much?

Fans are totally riding the nostalgia wave with That Darn Cat! It's such a classic feel-good flick that brings back tons of memories, and its quirky charm really resonates with people.

Not done arguing?

Next Cat Movies fight, picked for you.

Keep voting →