Greatest Alison Brie Performances of All Time
Sarah in Horse Girl or Trudy Campbell in Mad Men

Pick Your Favorite

SARAH IN HORSE GIRL

VS

TRUDY CAMPBELL IN MAD MEN
0%

Your GOAT List

Why This Battle Matters

Could there be a starker contrast than the enigma of Sarah in 'Horse Girl' versus the poised perfection of Trudy Campbell in 'Mad Men'? Here, in the Alison Brie Performances League, we're not just choosing favorites; we're defining what captivates us most about Brie’s eclectic range. Sarah’s spiraling mystery deeply challenges our empathy, while Trudy’s calculated charm redefines power within subtlety. As these roles collide, the stakes are high: this isn't just about who wins, it's about which performance resonates deeper, pushing the boundaries of Brie’s artistic legacy. What values will guide your choice today—unpredictability or understated strength?

🔥 Fan Takes

Honestly, Trudy Campbell? Classic power play in pearls and heels. Iconic.
Bro, Sarah in Horse Girl was like a whole trip — who even needs reality?
Trudy's got that vintage charm, y'all. Takes me right back to the 60s vibes!

How Fans Are Voting

In this battle:

The contenders are currently tied in head-to-head matchups. Your vote will break the tie.

Fan FAQs

Why do so many people admire Alison Brie's portrayal of Trudy Campbell on Mad Men?

Trudy Campbell is often praised for her charm and complexity, qualities that Alison Brie brings effortlessly to the screen. Fans appreciate her ability to balance Trudy's gracefulness with savvy, making her a standout character in a series filled with compelling personalities.

What makes Sarah in Horse Girl resonate with fans so much?

Fans are drawn to Sarah in Horse Girl because of Alison Brie's intense and immersive portrayal of a woman grappling with her mental health. The role is a departure from her other characters, showing her impressive range and ability to connect deeply with complex emotional themes.

Why is this matchup between Sarah in Horse Girl and Trudy Campbell in Mad Men so close?

Both roles showcase Alison Brie's versatility, but in very different ways. Sarah's deep dive into mental health captures fans who appreciate a raw, powerful performance, while Trudy's poised presence in Mad Men attracts those who love a more subtle, refined acting style. The fan base is split because both roles resonate on such different emotional levels.