The original consulting detective — and the smartest person in every room.
Sherlock Holmes solves crimes with razor-sharp logic, microscopic observation, and a confidence that borders on arrogance. Long before modern forensics, Holmes was reading footprints, cigar ash, and human behavior like open books.
Nearly every fictional detective owes him something. You can hear it in Hercule Poirot’s psychological precision, see it in Benoit Blanc’s theatrical reveals, and even trace it to Clarice Starling’s methodical profiling.
The debate among fans is simple:
Is Sherlock Holmes the greatest detective ever… or has he just had 130 years of unbeatable publicity?
Rank: #1 (see rankings)
Win Rate: 0.0%
Best matchups (highest win rate)
Worst matchups (lowest win rate)