Mr. Gatti’s Pizza

You didn't just go to Mr. Gatti's for pizza. You went for the whole experience. The buffet was only the beginning: endless slices, dessert pizza, and, at many locations, an arcade full of games waiting after dinner. Birthday parties, family nights, and trying to squeeze in one more slice before running back to the games made Mr. Gatti's feel like more than a restaurant. Cici's might have the unlimited pizza crowd, and Pizza Ranch brings fried chicken into the fight, but Mr. Gatti's has something neither can fully replicate: that pizza-party atmosphere. And against Pizza Hut Buffet, the childhood nostalgia battle gets even tougher. Was Mr. Gatti's the greatest pizza buffet experience ever? That's a fight worth settling.