Georgia Peach Ice Cream Sandwich

If there’s anything more divisive than politics at a family BBQ, it’s the Georgia Peach Ice Cream Sandwich debate at GoatWars. This contender in the Greatest Masters Menu Items of All Time doesn’t just melt under pressure—it thrives. Fans? Obsessed. They’ll argue over its unbeatable combo of fresh peaches and creamy dreaminess like it’s a sports team. And let’s be honest, choosing anything else feels like a betrayal to summer itself. It’s the dessert that launched a thousand picnics, and no one stays on the fence about it.