VS
Your GOAT List
Ever pondered how a joyous holiday escapade and a wild campus comedy can encapsulate the same hilarious genius? Welcome to the clash of Elf vs. Old School in our Greatest Will Ferrell Movies of All Time league. In one corner, the whimsical charm of Buddy the Elf, igniting the heart with Christmas spirit versus the raucous, rebellion-tinged antics of Frank the Tank, stirring nostalgia for wilder days. With legacy and humor at stake here, fans face a choice not just of film preference, but of the comedic soul they cherish most. Will you rally for innocent mirth or cheer for unruly fun?
In this battle:
Fans currently prefer Elf over Old School when it comes to the greatest Will Ferrell Movies of all time. In head-to-head matchups, fans pick Elf 81.8% of the time over Old School.
Across all battles:
Elf win rate: 78.0%
Old School win rate: 58.9%
This matchup is a clash of comedy styles: Elf's heartfelt, family-friendly humor versus Old School's more adult, party-time vibes. It's a classic battle between sweet nostalgia and raunchy laughs, making fans fiercely defend their favorite.
Old School's appeal lies in its raucous humor and the whole 'let's start a fraternity' angle which many find hilariously outrageous. It's a classic for those who appreciate Ferrell's wilder, more absurd comedy moments.
Elf is just smashing it! Fans love its holiday charm and the way it pulls on the heartstrings every Christmas season. It's hard not to vote for a movie that turns everyone into a kid again during the holidays. Old School is hilarious but doesn't quite hit those festive feels like Elf does.