VS
Your GOAT List
Can the raw passion of the underdog topple established prestige? This isn’t just a head-to-head bout; it’s James Street’s fearless, improvisational play against Chris Simms’s polished, powerhouse performances. Street, the legend who never lost a game as a starter, embodies the spirit of the old-school clutch player. In contrast, Simms, a product of modern football sophistication, represents the evolution of quarterback analytics and training. What’s at stake here goes beyond individual legacy—it's about which era of football resonates most deeply with fans today. Will the vote champion the gritty, gut-driven performances or the strategic, studied execution?
In this battle:
Fans currently prefer James Street over Chris Simms when it comes to the greatest University of Texas Quarterbacks of all time. In head-to-head matchups, fans pick James Street 66.7% of the time over Chris Simms.
Across all battles:
James Street win rate: 34.8%
Chris Simms win rate: 12.5%
The debate heats up because it's a classic clash of eras and styles. Street's old-school, gritty playmaking contrasts with Simms' more modern, statistically impressive college career. Fans are torn between historical impact and raw talent, making every vote a tough pick.
Chris Simms has his loyalists who admire his strong arm and the excitement he brought to the games during his time. Plus, being a part of a football family brings a bit of charm and nostalgia which definitely earns him some points.
James Street is leading mainly because fans remember his pivotal role in clinching the 1969 national championship with that legendary undefeated season. His knack for clutch plays and leadership in critical moments really resonates with the fanbase.