home ⟩ Pop Culture & Characters ⟩ The Office Characters ⟩ Andy Bernard vs. Dwight Schrute

Greatest The Office Characters of All Time
Andy Bernard or Dwight Schrute

Pick Your Favorite

ANDY BERNARD

VS

DWIGHT SCHRUTE
0%

Your GOAT List

Why This Battle Matters

Who can claim the true heart of Scranton? In the GoatWars ring, Andy Bernard's preppy charm collides with Dwight Schrute's beet-stained determination, setting the stage for a battle as memorable as Dunder Mifflin itself. Andy's spontaneous serenades and privileged naivety starkly contrast with Dwight’s relentless ambition and survivalist instincts. This isn’t just about who brought more laughs or cringes; it’s a showdown of Scranton’s soul, testing whether sheer earnestness or cunning resilience resonates deeper with fans. Whose legacy will rise as the quintessential embodiment of our favorite office?

🔥 Fan Takes

Honestly, choosing between Dwight and Andy? Brutal. But Dwight's like that one super effective, weirdly lovable coworker, you know?
oh lol remember when Andy sang at the office? pure vibes but dwight's got the iconic moments fr.
Dwight, obviously?? Andy's fun but come on, beet farms over boat songs any day!

How Fans Are Voting

In this battle:

Fans currently prefer Dwight Schrute over Andy Bernard when it comes to the greatest The Office Characters of all time. In head-to-head matchups, fans pick Dwight Schrute 100.0% of the time over Andy Bernard.

Across all battles:

Dwight Schrute win rate: 69.3%

Andy Bernard win rate: 7.1%

Fan FAQs

Why is this matchup such a big debate among fans of 'The Office'?

Andy Bernard vs. Dwight Schrute is a clash of distinct styles: Andy's earnest vulnerability versus Dwight's unshakeable confidence and bizarre tactics. Both characters bring depth and humor to the show in very different ways, sparking debates among fans about who truly holds the comedic crown in Scranton.

What makes Andy Bernard so beloved by The Office fans?

Fans love Andy Bernard for his evolving character arc—from the preppy, anger-prone salesman to a more lovable, albeit often clueless manager. His musical talents and emotional vulnerability add a unique flavor to Dunder Mifflin's ensemble that resonates with viewers.

Why is Dwight Schrute crushing Andy Bernard in the votes?

Dwight's victory margin is massive, and it's no surprise why! His quirky, intense personality and unforgettable antics have left a big mark on the show's legacy. Dwight is not just a character; he's become an icon synonymous with 'The Office,' making him a heavy favorite in fan votes.