home ⟩ Movies & TV ⟩ Taylor Sheridan Shows ⟩ Yellowstone vs. 1923

Greatest Taylor Sheridan Shows of All Time
Yellowstone or 1923

Pick Your Favorite

YELLOWSTONE

VS

1923
0%

Your GOAT List

Why This Battle Matters

Isn't it time we settled the score between tradition and rebellion? On one side, Yellowstone, a powerhouse of modern Western drama that redefined a genre with its blend of fierce family loyalty and ruthless ambition. On the other, 1923, the audacious prequel that digs deeper into the roots with a grittier look at the struggles that shaped the Dutton legacy. This battle isn't just about which show can claim the top spot; it's a tussle over which narrative style captures the essence of the American West. As fans, your preference will either preserve the prestige of established power or champion the boldness of new perspectives.

🔥 Fan Takes

Can't decide bro, both shows slap but Yellowstone's got that edge with the Dutton drama lol 😅🔥
Honestly, 1923 hits different. Old-school vibes & serious grit? It's a masterpiece, don't @ me.
Yellowstone keeps it 100 - drama, horses, and family feuds? Yes please! 🐎💥

How Fans Are Voting

In this battle:

The contenders are currently tied in head-to-head matchups. Your vote will break the tie.

Fan FAQs

Why do fans adore 1923?

1923 has quickly gathered a dedicated following due to its deep dive into the earlier Dutton family history, exploring themes of survival and adventure during the early 20th century. The show's ability to mix historical context with the personal drama of the Duttons keeps viewers hooked and coming back for more.

What makes Yellowstone stand out in the greatest Taylor Sheridan shows league?

Yellowstone captures hearts with its gripping portrayal of family loyalty and power struggles set against the vast, unforgiving American West. Its blend of raw, emotional storytelling sprinkled with action-packed scenes makes it a fan favorite and often places it at the top of Sheridan's creations.

Why is the matchup between Yellowstone and 1923 so tight?

It's a razor-thin battle because both shows have struck a chord with fans for different reasons. Yellowstone, with its epic family drama and stunning scenery, pulls in fans looking for intense, character-driven stories. 1923, although a newcomer, brings a fresh twist to the legacy, captivating those who love historical depth and new explorations in the Sheridan universe.