home ⟩ Movies & TV ⟩ Taylor Sheridan Shows ⟩ Yellowstone vs. 1883

Greatest Taylor Sheridan Shows of All Time
Yellowstone or 1883

Pick Your Favorite

YELLOWSTONE

VS

1883
0%

Your GOAT List

Why This Battle Matters

What does it truly mean to capture the rugged spirit of the American frontier? This is the question at the heart of our GoatWars showdown between Yellowstone and 1883. On one side, Yellowstone's contemporary saga of power and family loyalty engages viewers with its high-stakes drama and sweeping Montanan landscapes. On the flip side, 1883's raw, emotional portrayal of pioneering hardships offers a gritty historical perspective. The winner of this battle will not just lead in rankings but will define the essence of modern Western storytelling. Fans must decide: is the spirit of the West found in the legacy of its past or the drama of its present?

🔥 Fan Takes

why do we even compare? both shows have that Sheridan magic, but 1883 hits different fr.
1883 slaps tho, it's got depth n grit that's just 😙👌
Like, Yellowstone got me through some rough times, for real. I can't drop it now.

How Fans Are Voting

In this battle:

Fans currently prefer 1883 over Yellowstone when it comes to the greatest Taylor Sheridan Shows of all time. In head-to-head matchups, fans pick 1883 100.0% of the time over Yellowstone.

Across all battles:

1883 win rate: 78.6%

Yellowstone win rate: 39.3%

Fan FAQs

Why is this matchup between 1883 and Yellowstone such a big debate among fans?

This matchup hits hard because it pits the raw, historical grit of 1883 against the contemporary, high-stakes drama of Yellowstone. Both shows offer a glimpse into different eras of the American West, appealing to various fan preferences in storytelling and character development.

What makes Yellowstone so beloved by its fans even if it's currently trailing?

Yellowstone's appeal lies in its intense drama and complex characters, led by the formidable John Dutton. Fans are drawn to the modern cowboy struggle and the scenic vistas of Montana, making it a staple for those who love a mix of action, politics, and family drama.

Why is 1883 winning by so much against Yellowstone in the Greatest Taylor Sheridan Shows league?

Fans are absolutely loving 1883 for its raw portrayal of the early American frontier, which might be why it's sweeping the votes. The show's deep dive into the gritty realities of pioneer life connects emotionally, giving it a powerful edge over Yellowstone, despite the latter's popularity.