home ⟩ Pop Culture & Characters ⟩ SNL Cast Members ⟩ Maya Rudolph vs. Tina Fey

Greatest SNL Cast Members of All Time
Tina Fey or Maya Rudolph

Pick Your Favorite

TINA FEY

VS

MAYA RUDOLPH
0%

Your GOAT List

Why This Battle Matters

Who said laughter isn't a serious business? In the arena of GoatWars, the battle between Maya Rudolph and Tina Fey isn't just about chuckles—it's a showdown of comedic philosophy. Rudolph, with her versatile impressions and soulful singing antics, brought a unique flavor to SNL that contrasted with Fey's sharp, cerebral wit as the show's head writer and indomitable Weekend Update anchor. As fans debate, they're really deciding: Do we prefer our comedy served with a side of impersonations or a helping of satirical punch? This isn't just about who made us laugh more—it's about what kind of laughter resonates with the soul of our culture.

🔥 Fan Takes

Maya Rudolph hits different, y'all. The nostalgia is real. 🌟
Do we even remember SNL pre-Tina Fey? She's the blueprint, folks. Maya's great, but Tina is SNL royalty.
tbh Maya's impersonations? Iconic. But Tina literally wrote the rulebook on comedy gold. #queen

How Fans Are Voting

In this battle:

Fans currently prefer Tina Fey over Maya Rudolph when it comes to the greatest SNL Cast Members of all time. In head-to-head matchups, fans pick Tina Fey 69.2% of the time over Maya Rudolph.

Across all battles:

Tina Fey win rate: 57.1%

Maya Rudolph win rate: 43.5%

Fan FAQs

Why is this matchup between Tina Fey and Maya Rudolph such a big deal?

This face-off is huge because it pits two of SNL's most iconic women against each other. Both have left indelible marks on the show with their distinct comedic styles—Tina with her sharp and incisive satire, and Maya with her dynamic character work, making it a debate not just about talent but also about comedic preferences.

What makes Maya Rudolph so beloved by fans?

Fans love Maya Rudolph for her versatile performances and impeccable comedic timing. Her ability to transform into any character, from Beyoncé to Oprah, not only showcases her talent but also makes her sketches memorable and uniquely hilarious.

Why is Tina Fey currently leading in the Greatest SNL Cast Members league on GoatWars?

Tina Fey is taking the lead largely because of her sharp wit and groundbreaking role as a head writer on SNL. Fans adore her smart humor and memorable parodies, especially her portrayal of Sarah Palin, which has left a lasting impression.