Greatest SNL Cast Members of All Time
Dan Aykroyd or Kate McKinnon
Pick Your Favorite
VS
Your GOAT List
Why This Battle Matters
Who truly holds the torch for comedic brilliance on Saturday nights? Is it the spectral shapeshifter Kate McKinnon, whose impressions warp reality, or the vintage cool of Dan Aykroyd, whose comedic rigidity provided the backbone for SNL's early years? This isn't just a battle of talent, but a clash of epochs in SNL history — the spontaneous modernity of McKinnon versus the scripted precision of Aykroyd. What hangs in the balance is not merely a spot on the GOAT list, but a reflection on the evolving nature of comedy itself. Who represents the soul of SNL to you, the vivid innovator or the steadfast pioneer?
🔥 Fan Takes
How Fans Are Voting
In this battle:
The contenders are currently tied in head-to-head matchups. Your vote will break the tie.
Fan FAQs
What's behind Dan Aykroyd's enduring popularity?
Dan Aykroyd's charm lies in his originality and his role in defining the early years of SNL. Fans love his sharp wit, impeccable timing, and memorable characters like the Blues Brothers. His influence runs deep, shaping not just SNL but the entire landscape of comedy.
What makes Kate McKinnon so beloved by SNL fans?
Kate McKinnon is adored for her wild range of character impressions and her ability to steal the show in any sketch. Her infectious energy and fearless commitment to her roles, from the bizarre to the politically poignant, really make her a standout star in modern SNL history.
Why is the matchup between Kate McKinnon and Dan Aykroyd so evenly split?
This head-to-head is so close because fans are torn between two eras of SNL greatness. Kate McKinnon's recent, versatile performances strike a chord with newer audiences, while Dan Aykroyd's classic, foundational work resonates with long-time watchers. Each brings a unique flavor to the SNL table that’s hard to compare directly!