Greatest SNL Cast Members of All Time
Amy Poehler or Kate McKinnon
Pick Your Favorite
VS
Your GOAT List
Why This Battle Matters
What happens when a master of impersonation meets a queen of improv? In the SNL Cast Members league, Kate McKinnon vs. Amy Poehler isn't just a battle—it's a full-blown war over who defines the golden era of Saturday Night Live. McKinnon, with her chameleon-like transformations, brings a modern flair that defies expectation, while Poehler's razor-sharp wit and fearless comedy have set a high bar for what it means to lead. This isn't just about who made us laugh more; it's about whose style will stand the test of time as the emblem of SNL greatness. Which cornerstone of comedy do you believe is the true backbone of SNL's legacy?
🔥 Fan Takes
How Fans Are Voting
In this battle:
Fans currently prefer Kate McKinnon over Amy Poehler when it comes to the greatest SNL Cast Members of all time. In head-to-head matchups, fans pick Kate McKinnon 78.9% of the time over Amy Poehler.
Across all battles:
Kate McKinnon win rate: 55.8%
Amy Poehler win rate: 43.7%
Fan FAQs
Who's the #1 contender on GoatWars in the Greatest SNL Cast Members league?
Currently, Tina Fey holds the top spot in the Greatest SNL Cast Members league. You can check her out and see where others rank on the GOAT List.
What's the big debate between Kate McKinnon and Amy Poehler on GoatWars?
It's a clash of comedy styles and eras! Kate’s wacky, transformative comedy contrasts sharply with Amy's smart, snappy delivery. Fans of SNL are torn because both cast members brought so much to the show during their times, making this one of the hot topics in GoatWars.
Why is Kate McKinnon leading by so much against Amy Poehler in the Greatest SNL Cast Members league?
Kate McKinnon's unique style and the wide range of characters she's brought to life on SNL seem to really resonate with the fans. Her ability to steal the scene, whether it’s through a quirky impersonation or a wild character, has created a strong emotional bond with the audience, propelling her to a significant lead.