Greatest SNL Cast Members of All Time
Bill Murray or Amy Poehler
Pick Your Favorite
VS
Your GOAT List
Why This Battle Matters
Who better symbolizes the evergreen debate of classic vs. modern SNL than the laid-back king of deadpan, Bill Murray, and the razor-sharp queen of smart comedy, Amy Poehler? This battle isn't just about who made us laugh more; it's about which comedic philosophy shapes what Saturday Night Live stands for today. Murray brought a rebellious, sardonic wit that defined a generation, while Poehler's fearless, fast-paced humor pushed boundaries in new directions. As fans, your preference isn't just a check in a box; it's a vote on whether SNL’s soul lies in its clever subtlety or in its bold, unapologetic approach. What does your laugh say about you?
🔥 Fan Takes
How Fans Are Voting
In this battle:
Fans currently prefer Bill Murray over Amy Poehler when it comes to the greatest SNL Cast Members of all time. In head-to-head matchups, fans pick Bill Murray 66.7% of the time over Amy Poehler.
Across all battles:
Bill Murray win rate: 47.9%
Amy Poehler win rate: 45.5%
Fan FAQs
Why is Bill Murray winning by such a notable margin?
Bill Murray's comedic timing and memorable characters resonate with fans who admire the impact he had during his time on SNL. The nostalgia factor and his continued success in film likely contribute to his significant lead in the votes.
Why do fans love Amy Poehler so much?
Amy Poehler is a fan favorite for her boundless energy and versatility on SNL. Her impressions and the iconic 'Weekend Update' segments really showcased her comedic brilliance and endeared her to a generation.
Who has the edge in the Greatest SNL Cast Members of All Time league, Amy Poehler or Bill Murray?
Right now, Bill Murray is leading over Amy Poehler. Fans seem to be really vibing with Bill's classic, laid-back comedic style and his iconic moments on SNL from the late '70s.