Greatest Sitcoms of all time

It’s Always Sunny in Philadelphia vs The Mary Tyler Moore Show

Two picks. One winner. No fence-sitting.

The Real Debate

It’s Always Sunny in Philadelphia thrives on chaos and irreverence, while The Mary Tyler Moore Show embodies the pioneering spirit of a controlled, character-driven comedy. In this epic sitcom showdown, fans are torn between Sunny’s no-holds-barred humor and Mary’s groundbreaking role in shaping TV heroines. The battle isn't just about laughs; it's a clash between modern anarchy and classic charm, where loyalty to one’s generational icon tests the waters of comedic taste. Will you side with the gang’s wild antics or root for Mary’s inspiring resilience in a man’s world? Cast your vote and tip the scales in this comedic tug-of-war!

Head-to-Head Comparison

Criteria Edge Why
Laughs It’s Always Sunny in Philadelphia It's Always Sunny's edgy humor and absurd scenarios consistently deliver gut-busting laughs.
Characters It’s Always Sunny in Philadelphia The gang's outrageous antics and flawed personalities in It's Always Sunny make them unforgettable.
Rewatchability It’s Always Sunny in Philadelphia The non-linear, episodic format of It's Always Sunny invites frequent rewatching without continuity concerns.
Iconic Moments The Mary Tyler Moore Show The Mary Tyler Moore Show's groundbreaking subject matter and memorable episodes left a lasting imprint on television.
 It’s Always Sunny in Philadelphia vs. The Mary Tyler Moore Show

Fan Takes

while the Mary Tyler Moore Show laid the groundwork for female leads, it's always sunny embodies the absurdity of friendship in a way that's so... real. It's like watching the messy side of life unravel in the funniest ways. Totally different vibes, but both are classic in their own right!
it's always sunny is like the chaotic middle child of sitcoms lol. who doesn't love a bit of mayhem, right? fr, it's iconic.
man, i grew up watching mary tyler moore every day after school. it just hits different! nostalgia overload 😂

How Fans Are Voting

Latest battle odds:

The Mary Tyler Moore Show: 67%

It’s Always Sunny in Philadelphia: 33%

Overall battle results:

Overall fans prefer It’s Always Sunny in Philadelphia over The Mary Tyler Moore Show when it comes to the greatest Sitcoms of all time. In head-to-head matchups, fans pick It’s Always Sunny in Philadelphia 55.2% of the time over The Mary Tyler Moore Show.

Across all battles:

It’s Always Sunny in Philadelphia win rate: 36.1%

The Mary Tyler Moore Show win rate: 46.0%

Fan FAQs

Who is better: It’s Always Sunny in Philadelphia or The Mary Tyler Moore Show?

'It’s Always Sunny' is currently leading and honestly, it's hard not to love the outrageous antics of the gang! Fans appreciate the show’s unique humor and how it pushes boundaries, making it a solid contender in the Greatest Sitcoms of All Time league. Want the whole picture? The GOAT List for Greatest Sitcoms of All Time ranks every contender.

What makes The Mary Tyler Moore Show so popular?

'The Mary Tyler Moore Show' vibes with fans for its groundbreaking portrayal of a working woman and its iconic cast. Plus, who doesn’t love a show that mixes laughter with genuine warmth? It’s a classic that’s stood the test of time.

Why is this matchup so close?

Fans are seriously divided on this one! Both shows have passionate followings—'It’s Always Sunny' brings that wild, edgy humor while 'The Mary Tyler Moore Show' delivers heartfelt moments that resonate with so many. It's like choosing between comfort food and a spicy dish!

Not done arguing?

Next Sitcoms fight, picked for you.

Keep voting →